Sequence of Returns Risk: Same Returns, Different Retirement
Sarah and James each retire with $1 million and take $50,000 a year from their investments. Over the next four years, they get exactly the same returns, just in a different order.
By the end of year four, Sarah has $62,700 less than James.
Year 1 · Sarah −10% → $850,000 · James +20% → $1,150,000
Year 2 · Sarah −10% → $715,000 · James +20% → $1,330,000
Year 3 · Sarah +20% → $808,000 · James −10% → $1,147,000
Year 4 · Sarah +20% → $919,600 · James −10% → $982,300
Returns and balances are in today’s dollars. Withdrawals happen at the end of each year. The example leaves out taxes and fees.
Without withdrawals, both portfolios would finish at $1,166,400. But Sarah is taking money out while her portfolio is shrinking. When the rebound comes, she has less invested to benefit from it. That’s sequence of returns risk.
There’s another way to see the strain. At the start of retirement, $50,000 was 5% of Sarah’s portfolio. Entering year three, that same withdrawal is about 7% of what she has left. Her spending hasn’t changed. What it asks of her portfolio has.
Does a retirement bucket strategy help?
The appeal of a cash buffer is easy to see. If Sarah had two years of expenses set aside, she could pay her bills through the downturn without selling shares. Over a 30-year retirement, though, part of her portfolio would be sitting in cash even when markets were doing well. And if interest on that cash lagged inflation, the buffer would lose purchasing power.
Finance professor Javier Estrada tested this idea using historical data from 1900 to 2014. He compared cash-bucket strategies with portfolios that maintained a fixed mix of stocks and bonds. The fixed allocations generally performed better across the measures he examined. In a separate study covering 19 countries and the world market, both an all-stock portfolio and a fixed 60/40 mix held up well against strategies that gradually raised or lowered their exposure to stocks. Cash-bucket study · International retirement glide-path study
The result that surprised me most came from a working paper by Aizhan Anarkulova, Scott Cederburg and Michael O’Doherty. In one version of their model, the household followed the 4% rule, taking 4% of its starting portfolio in year one and adjusting that dollar amount for inflation thereafter. When the researchers let the investment mix change with age, the model briefly favoured holding some short-term bills around retirement. When they gave the household a more flexible withdrawal rule, that temporary allocation disappeared. The investment mix the model favoured depended on how the household planned to spend. Beyond the Status Quo, working-paper version
What if the withdrawal changed with the balance?
One way to make spending flexible is to recalculate the withdrawal each year. Start with what’s left in the portfolio, make an assumption about future returns after inflation, and spread the balance over the remaining years. A bad year can mean a smaller withdrawal next year. A recovery can give some of that spending back. The trade-off is that more of the market’s ups and downs show up in your annual budget. How variable percentage withdrawals work
You can see the effect without committing to a formula. Say Sarah could spend $45,000 in each of the first two years and go back to $50,000 in year three. With the same returns, she’d finish year four with $933,280. She spent $10,000 less and ended up with $13,680 more in her portfolio. The extra $3,680 came from leaving those dollars invested through the recovery.
Of course, that only works if Sarah has $5,000 a year she can actually give up. A trip can wait. Rent, groceries and insurance usually can’t. And if the downturn lasts five years, postponing one trip may buy less breathing room than she needs.
That’s the comparison I’d make in WealthScout. I’d put the household’s expected income and expenses into two retirement projections, keep the investment assumptions the same, and change the timing of an expense I could genuinely defer. Seeing those plans side by side would help me judge whether the adjustment makes enough difference to be worth making.
If I retired into two bad years, what could I realistically spend less on, and how long could I keep that up?